Search This Blog

Showing posts with label regulation and banks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label regulation and banks. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 4, 2012

We don't need no regulation



In the NYTimes, an argument for tighter bank regulation

Governments should fully guarantee all bank deposits — and impose much tighter restrictions on risk-taking by banks. Banks should be forced to shed activities like derivatives trading that regulators cannot easily examine.

Right now in the U.S. FDIC insurance only covers $250,000. The author argues that if all deposits were 100% guarenteed, there would be fewer bank runs and financial crises would not be so bad. To mitigate risky lending, the government should act as a tight regulator, and ban trading in financial instruments like derivatives.

AM: Unfortunately, the author does not address some of the counterarguments. Fully insured deposits would create a major moral hazard problem as the rich depositers would not care at all what banks did with their money. This problem already exists to some degree, I would imagine, with insured deposits. The author would likely counter that "this is the point of regulation." I would respond: "you have a lot of faith in regulators."

There is no resolving this one, but the contours are familar: which way should we choose, more bottom up or more top down? I have more faith in bottom up. Banks don't 'self regulate' but they do act in their own self-interest and respond to incentives. Risk taking has been fed by a culture of bail outs, which created a massive moral hazard problem. FDIC insurance (and bail outs in general) perverts incentives, and so you need top down oversight, sure. But that creates its own problems: regulators don't have perfect information; they are subject to capture by private and political interests; they create new burdens of compliance and new inefficiencies.